Amazon Basics Dog and Puppy Pee Pads Review - Unbeatable Value for 2024
Comprehensive review of Amazon Basics Dog and Puppy Pee Pads after 4 months of real-world testing. The budget king of training pads with FSC-certified materials.
Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
When Amazon enters a product category, they typically deliver solid quality at aggressive pricing - and their puppy pads are no exception. After using Amazon Basics Dog and Puppy Pee Pads exclusively for four months with two foster puppies, we have a clear picture of their strengths and limitations. These pads won't win any awards for premium features, but for pure value-per-pad, nothing else comes close. Here's our detailed breakdown of whether the savings are worth any tradeoffs.
Amazon Basics Dog and Puppy Pee Pads
Key Features
- ✓FSC-certified materials from responsibly managed forests
- ✓5-layer leak-proof construction with gel-lock core
- ✓Built-in attractant to encourage pad usage
- ✓22x22 inch standard size with 1.65 inch border
Pros
- +Lowest cost per pad at $0.14-0.17 depending on quantity purchased
- +Built-in attractant genuinely helps puppies find the pad faster
- +FSC certification means environmentally responsible sourcing
Cons
- −Thinner construction than premium brands - holds about 2 cups max
- −No odor-neutralizing technology - just basic absorption
Breaking Down the True Cost Per Pad
Let's talk numbers, because that's where Amazon Basics shines brightest. A 150-count box runs approximately $21.49, which works out to just $0.143 per pad. Compare that to Glad at $0.25/pad or Four Paws Wee-Wee at $0.35/pad, and you're looking at 40-60% savings. During the intensive first months of puppy training when you might use 6-8 pads daily, that's a difference of $15-25 per week. Over a typical 3-month training period, choosing Amazon Basics could save you $180-300 compared to premium brands. That's real money.
The Built-In Attractant Actually Works
We were skeptical about the 'built-in attractant' claim - it sounds like marketing fluff. But in a controlled test, we placed an Amazon Basics pad next to a generic unscented pad with our 10-week-old foster puppy. Over 20 observed accidents, she chose the Amazon Basics pad 16 times (80%). The attractant has a subtle ammonia-like scent that mimics the smell dogs naturally seek for elimination. It's not a magic solution - you still need proper training techniques - but it provides a genuine assist during the learning phase.
5-Layer Construction: What's Actually Inside
Amazon claims 5-layer protection, and after dissecting several pads, we can confirm the construction: (1) quilted non-woven top layer, (2) tissue distribution layer, (3) absorbent fluff pulp core with SAP (super absorbent polymer), (4) tissue layer, and (5) polyethylene leak-proof backing. The notable difference from premium pads is the amount of SAP - Amazon uses less, which explains the roughly 2-cup capacity versus 3.5+ cups in premium options. For small to medium puppies with normal hydration, this is usually adequate. For large breed puppies or dogs with excessive urination, you may need to change pads more frequently.
FSC Certification: An Unexpected Bonus
Something we didn't expect from a budget product: FSC certification (FSC N004130). This means the wood pulp materials come from responsibly managed forests, recycled materials, or controlled wood sources. For environmentally conscious pet owners who feel guilty about disposable pad waste, this provides some peace of mind that at least the raw materials are sourced responsibly. It's a small detail, but notable for a budget product.
Where Amazon Basics Falls Short
Let's be honest about the weaknesses. First, odor control is minimal - there's no activated carbon or odor-neutralizing technology, so used pads smell exactly like you'd expect. Second, the 'quick-dry' surface isn't as fast as premium brands; our puppy tracked wet paw prints a few times after immediate pad use. Third, the usable center area (19x19 inches) is smaller than the advertised 22x22 overall size due to the border. For puppies over 30 pounds, consider sizing up to the Large or X-Large options.
Final Verdict
Amazon Basics Dog and Puppy Pee Pads earn our 'Best Value' recommendation without hesitation. They're not the most absorbent, they don't control odors, and they're not the fastest-drying. But at literally half the cost of premium alternatives, they provide perfectly adequate performance for standard puppy training. Our recommendation: use Amazon Basics for everyday training, and keep a small stash of premium pads (like Glad Charcoal) for situations where odor control matters - like when guests are visiting or in smaller apartments. This hybrid approach gives you the best of both worlds while keeping costs reasonable.